They are both right:
the cape uses i2c2_scl | P9_19 and i2c2_sda | P9_20, which is bus I2C2, for the audio codec. However, the pin diagram recommends that you use I2C1 for connecting external devices, and that's on P9.24 and P9.26.

EDIT: I2C2 remains largely free (except address 0x18, used by the codec) if you need to use it for something else

I2C2 remains largely free (except address 0x18, used by the codec) if you need to use it for something else